Skip to content
Certified by The CPD Certification Service, UK
Probity & Ethics banner with the words "Facing an Allegation of Unethical Behaviour or Conduct?" beside a drawing of a document with a shield and a tick

Facing an Allegation of Unethical Behaviour or Conduct?

What unethical conduct means, how regulators judge it and which course fits.

Dr Shehzad Iqbal

Share

An allegation of unethical behaviour or unethical conduct means someone says a decision or an action of yours went against the ethical duties your regulator sets: respect for a patient’s dignity and choices, consent, confidentiality, fairness, or not using your position for your own gain. The first steps are to read the allegation against your regulator’s standards, take advice, and start remediation that matches the concern. Our Probity & Ethics medical ethics course, the CPD course Medical Ethics Course, covers these duties for a complaint or investigation and for your CPD.

Key Takeaways

  • An allegation of unethical behaviour says a decision or an action went against the ethical duties in your regulator’s standards.
  • Consent, confidentiality, dignity, discrimination, conflicts of interest and abuse of trust are the areas these allegations cover.
  • A regulator asks whether the conduct is serious enough for a fitness to practise investigation and whether the concern can be addressed.
  • Insight is central to how a regulator decides whether your fitness to practise is currently impaired.
  • A course that matches the allegation, with a written reflection, is dated evidence of remediation you can choose to send with your response.

What does an allegation of unethical conduct mean?

Regulators do not use “unethical conduct” as a legal term. A complaint, an employer or a regulator uses the words to say your conduct broke one of the ethical duties in your standards. It sits beside two other allegations with their own guides: an allegation of unprofessional conduct is about how you behaved, and an allegation of dishonesty is about the truth of what you said or wrote. An allegation of unethical conduct is about whether a decision respected the patient and was fair. Examples include:

  • treating a patient without valid consent, or going ahead when the patient had said no;
  • sharing a patient’s information without a lawful reason, including in a message or a post;
  • treating a patient or a colleague less fairly because of who they are;
  • a conflict of interest that was not declared, such as a referral to a business you have a stake in, or accepting a gift that could look like it affected your care;
  • using your position to gain something from a patient or a colleague.

What do the regulators’ standards say about ethical conduct?

Each regulator writes these duties in its own words. The GMC’s page on the duties of medical professionals asks doctors to respect every patient’s dignity, never unfairly discriminate against patients or colleagues, and “never abuse patients’ trust in you or the public’s trust in your profession”.

RegulatorDocumentWhat it says about ethical conduct
GMC (doctors, physician associates, anaesthesia associates)Good medical practiceRespect dignity and privacy, be satisfied you have consent before examining or treating, treat information about patients as confidential, and do not discriminate.
NMC (nurses, midwives, nursing associates)The CodeAct in the best interests of people at all times, get properly informed consent and document it, refuse gifts, favours or hospitality unless they are trivial, and uphold the reputation of your profession.
HCPC (health and care professions)Standards of conduct, performance and ethicsPromote and protect the interests of service users and carers, respect their privacy and dignity, do not abuse your position, and declare issues that might create conflicts of interest.
GDC (dental team)Standards for the Dental TeamPut patients’ interests first, before any financial, personal or other gain, obtain valid consent, and protect patients’ information.
GPhC (pharmacists, pharmacy technicians)Standards for pharmacy professionalsTreat people with respect and safeguard their dignity, do not abuse your position, and declare any personal or professional interests and manage them professionally.

The GDC and GPhC standards also make clear that the duties apply in your personal life and outside working hours, so an allegation can be about conduct away from work.

How does a regulator decide whether the allegation is serious?

Not every breach leads to action. The NMC’s screening guidance says “not every breach of the professional standards set out in the Code” needs regulatory action, and a concern is serious where it is a serious departure from the Code and poses an ongoing risk to public safety, public confidence or professional standards. It names discriminatory behaviour, whether or not it relates to practice, as one of the serious examples.

The regulator then asks whether the concern can be addressed. The NMC’s guidance on whether a concern can be addressed says clinical failings in a clear area of practice are easier to address, while conduct that shows an underlying problem with attitude, or discrimination inside or outside practice, is harder. The GMC’s guidance on decisions on undertakings makes a similar point: undertakings are unlikely to be enough where the concerns suggest an underlying attitudinal problem, and they are more likely to be workable where the doctor has shown insight. An allegation of unethical conduct can be read as a question about attitude, which is why your response needs to show understanding and not only a course.

What should you do first after an allegation of unethical conduct?

  1. Take advice before you reply. Speak to your defence organisation, indemnity provider or union before you send anything to your employer or your regulator.
  2. Find the duty. Read the allegation against your own regulator’s standards and name the duty it says you broke: consent, confidentiality, dignity, fairness or a conflict of interest.
  3. Write down the facts while they are fresh. Dates, what was said, what the record shows, and who else was present.
  4. Start remediation that matches the duty. A course on the right subject, finished early, shows the change began before anyone asked for it.
  5. Write a reflection. In your own words, say what you now understand about the effect on the patient or the colleague and what you do differently.

The stages that follow, from triage to a hearing, are set out in our guide to facing a fitness to practise investigation.

Which course fits an allegation of unethical conduct?

Match the course to the duty the allegation names. Each is online and self-paced, with a certificate on completion.

  • A clinical decision, consent, capacity or confidentiality: the Medical Ethics Course, £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10), 2.5 CPD hours. It covers consent, capacity, confidentiality, avoiding harm and fairness, the four principles and how to reason through a clinical decision.
  • Ethics across your practice, including conflicts of interest and boundaries: Ethics for Healthcare Professionals, £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10), 2 CPD hours. It covers the ethical principles that apply across healthcare, consent and capacity, confidentiality, honesty and candour, boundaries and conflicts of interest.
  • Unfair treatment of a patient or a colleague: Ensuring Dignity and Non-Discrimination as Healthcare Professionals, £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10), 2 CPD hours.

Where one allegation touches two duties, such as consent and confidentiality, two courses can each take one duty in more depth: Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice and Ensuring Confidentiality in Healthcare Practice, each £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours. Choose by the words of the allegation, not by the course you think will look best.

Where the allegation is about dishonesty, our probity course is the closer match, and for a boundary with a patient or a colleague, our professional boundaries course. If you are not sure which subject the allegation points to, our fitness to practise support page sets out the courses by concern, and our home page lists our remediation and CPD courses for healthcare professionals for every regulator.

How do the reflection and the certificate fit your response?

The NMC’s guidance on insight and strengthened practice says insight will be central to deciding whether fitness to practise is currently impaired, and asks whether the concern has been addressed and whether it is highly unlikely to be repeated. The certificate shows you finished a course on the right subject; the reflection shows you understood why the decision was wrong for the patient or the colleague. For an allegation of unethical conduct, your reflection can name the duty, explain what the patient or the colleague lost (a choice, their privacy, fair treatment), say what you now do before a decision of the same kind, and give dated changes someone else can confirm, such as a consent process you now record or an interest you have declared to your employer. Send both with your written response, through your adviser. The same course counts towards your CPD for appraisal, revalidation or renewal, and Probity & Ethics is CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service.

Book now: Medical Ethics Course

For healthcare professionals facing an allegation of unethical conduct, and for CPD

Medical Ethics Course

Consent, capacity, confidentiality, avoiding harm and fairness, the four principles and how to reason through a clinical decision, with reflection and remediation after a concern. Probity & Ethics is CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service (provider no. 13197).

  • £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10)
  • 2.5 CPD hours
  • Certificate on completion

Please note

This guide is for general information and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your situation, contact a specialist regulatory solicitor or your medical defence organisation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which course should I take for a complaint or investigation?

Our CPD certified and accredited course for this follows your regulator’s standards; pair it with a written reflection that names the standard engaged.

Will a course help my fitness to practise case?

A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which case examiners or an investigating committee look for — strongest with a written reflection and changes in your practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.

When should I send the certificate and reflection?

With your written response, before case examiners or an investigating committee decide — or before a fitness to practise hearing or a review if the case has gone further.

Can I finish the course before my deadline, and is it CPD accredited?

Yes — it is online and self-paced with a certificate on completion, and CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service, counting towards your CPD and revalidation.

Facing an allegation of unethical behaviour? What does it mean?

It means someone says a decision or an action of yours went against the ethical duties in your regulator’s standards, such as consent, confidentiality, dignity, fair treatment or not abusing your position. Take advice, read the allegation against your standards and start remediation that matches the duty named.

Is unethical conduct the same as misconduct?

Not exactly. Misconduct is the wider term a regulator uses for conduct that falls short of its standards. An allegation of unethical conduct is one kind of misconduct allegation, about whether a decision respected the patient and was fair.

Can an allegation of unethical conduct be about something outside work?

Yes. The GDC standards cover conduct at work and in your personal life, and the GPhC standards apply at all times, not only during working hours. The NMC names discriminatory behaviour as serious whether or not it relates to practice.

Does an ethics course end a fitness to practise investigation?

No. No course decides the outcome of a case. A course on the right subject, with a written reflection, is dated evidence of insight and remediation that you can choose to include with your response.

Which course fits an allegation about consent or confidentiality?

The Medical Ethics Course covers consent, capacity and confidentiality and how to reason through a clinical decision, for 2.5 CPD hours at £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10). Ethics for Healthcare Professionals takes a wider view across practice.

The CPD courses linked from this guide, Medical Ethics Course, Ethics for Healthcare Professionals, Ensuring Dignity and Non-Discrimination as Healthcare Professionals and Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice, are by Probity & Ethics, written by Dr Shehzad Iqbal, CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service (provider no. 13197) and offered since 2020.

Basket 0 Total £0.00