If you are accused of a boundaries breach with a patient or a colleague, the first steps are the same whoever raised it: take advice before you say anything in writing, keep every record and message, stay away from the person involved, and start to look honestly at what happened. Our Probity & Ethics professional boundaries course, the CPD course Professional Boundaries for Clinicians, helps you understand the breach and show your insight to an employer or a regulator, and it counts towards your CPD.
Key Takeaways
- A boundaries breach with a patient or a colleague can lead to an employer’s inquiry and a fitness to practise investigation by your regulator.
- Take advice from your defence organisation, indemnity provider or union before you reply to anyone.
- Do not contact the patient or colleague about the allegation, and do not delete messages or change records.
- Regulators judge a boundaries concern by the power you held, the harm caused and whether it could happen again.
- Insight and remediation started early can be shown in your response to the investigation.
What counts as a boundaries breach with a patient or a colleague?
A boundaries breach is conduct that moves a professional relationship into a personal, sexual, emotional or financial one, or uses the power of your role for something other than care or work. With a patient it can be a comment about their body, contact on a personal phone, a gift that creates an obligation, or a relationship. With a colleague it can be sexual remarks, unwanted messages, or a relationship with someone whose job or progress you control.
The regulators’ guidance makes two points that matter at the start. The GMC’s guidance on maintaining personal and professional boundaries says sexual behaviour does not have to involve touching: comments, “banter”, gestures and explicit messages are on its list. It also says not every departure from the guidance will be treated as serious. If you want the full step-by-step response once the first days are over, our guide on how to respond to a boundaries violation allegation takes you through it.
What should you do first, by who raised the concern?
How you hear about the allegation shapes the first few days.
- A patient complained to your practice or hospital. Ask your manager for the complaint in writing and agree who takes over the patient’s care. Record the handover. Do not reply to the patient yourself, even to apologise, until you have taken advice.
- A colleague reported you to your employer. Read your employer’s policy on the process. Ask what the allegation is, who will investigate, and whether you can bring a union representative or colleague to meetings. Agree how your rotas or contact with the colleague will be arranged in the meantime.
- Your regulator wrote to you. Note the date your response is due. The GDC’s standards, for example, say you must respond fully within the time given in its letter. Do not send a quick reply to meet a deadline: ask your adviser to request more time if you need it.
- The police are involved. Get legal advice at once. Check what your regulator’s standards say about telling it: the GDC’s standards say you must inform it immediately if you are subject to criminal proceedings.
Whichever route it came by, write a private note for your adviser while your memory is clear: dates, places, who was present, and what was said or sent. Keep it private, and do not add it to any patient record.
What should you avoid in the first days?
- Contacting the person. A message to explain or to ask them to withdraw the complaint can be seen as pressure, and can become a second concern.
- Deleting or editing anything. Messages, social media posts, emails and clinical notes stay as they are. A changed record turns a boundaries concern into an honesty concern.
- Talking about it at work. Discussing the allegation with colleagues who may be witnesses can affect the investigation.
- Posting online. Nothing about the case, the person or your feelings about it.
- Writing a defensive statement. A first response that blames the patient or the colleague, or says the other person agreed, works against you. The GPhC’s guidance says a pharmacy professional stays responsible for the boundary even when a relationship is agreed by everyone involved, and the other regulators take the same view of power.
How do regulators judge a boundaries breach?
Each regulator has its own words, but the questions are close. The table shows what four of them say.
| Regulator | What its standards or guidance say |
|---|---|
| GMC | You must not pursue a sexual or improper emotional relationship with a current patient. With a former patient, the GMC lists factors such as the time since care ended, how vulnerable the patient was and is, and whether you would be using your position. Relationships between colleagues who both agree are a private matter, but the risk is higher where there is a large power difference. |
| GDC | The Standards for the Dental Team say you must keep appropriate boundaries in your relationships with patients and must not take advantage of your position, and your conduct at work and in your personal life must justify patients’ trust. |
| GPhC | Its guidance on maintaining clear sexual boundaries says it is the pharmacy professional’s responsibility to be aware of the imbalance of power, that the same principles apply to former patients and carers, and that you must not act on feelings of attraction to a person in your care. |
| HCPC | The standards of conduct, performance and ethics ask you to set and keep appropriate professional boundaries with service users, carers and colleagues, and not to abuse your position to pursue personal, sexual, emotional or financial relationships with any of them. |
From this, an investigation will look at the power you held over the patient or the colleague, how vulnerable they were, whether the conduct was a single event or a pattern, the harm caused, and whether you understand why it was wrong. The GMC notes that the warning signs before a serious breach can include gifts, social invitations, sharing personal contact details and seeing a patient at unusual times. Our guide on sexual boundaries with patients and colleagues covers the sexual side of these cases in more depth.
How can you look honestly at what happened?
Before any course or reflection, answer these questions for yourself, in writing:
- When did the relationship stop being only professional, and did I notice at the time?
- What did my role give me: access to their body, their records, their rota, their job or their trust?
- Could they have said no to me easily? What would it have cost them?
- Who else was affected: other patients, the team, the people close to the person?
- What would I do differently from the first sign, and who would I tell?
These answers are the start of insight. They are also the material your reflection will need later, so keep them with your private notes.
Which course fits an allegation of a boundaries breach?
Professional Boundaries for Clinicians fits a breach about conduct: comments, touch, intimate care and chaperones, a relationship with a patient or a colleague, or messages. Where the allegation is about a decision you made, such as a dual relationship, a gift or favouritism towards a colleague, Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues fits. Each is online and self-paced, £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, with an assessment and a dated certificate. Probity & Ethics is CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service.
Starting early matters. A course and reflection dated soon after the allegation show that you acted on it yourself, before anyone asked. Courses written around each regulator’s standards are on our GDC remediation courses, GPhC remediation courses and HCPC remediation courses pages, and our home page lists our remediation and CPD courses for healthcare professionals for every regulator. If the case has already reached your regulator, our guide on facing a fitness to practise investigation explains the stages.
Book now: our professional boundaries course
For healthcare professionals accused of a boundaries breach with a patient or a colleague, and for CPD
Professional Boundaries for Clinicians
Boundaries with patients and former patients, intimate care and chaperones, power at work, boundaries with colleagues and online, with reflection and remediation for your response. Probity & Ethics is CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service (provider no. 13197).
- £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10)
- 2 CPD hours
- Certificate on completion
Please note
This guide is for general information and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your situation, contact a specialist regulatory solicitor or your medical defence organisation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which course should I take for a complaint or investigation?
Our CPD certified and accredited course for this follows your regulator’s standards; pair it with a written reflection that names the standard engaged.
Will a course help my fitness to practise case?
A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which case examiners or an investigating committee look for — strongest with a written reflection and changes in your practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
When should I send the certificate and reflection?
With your written response, before case examiners or an investigating committee decide — or before a fitness to practise hearing or a review if the case has gone further.
Can I finish the course before my deadline, and is it CPD accredited?
Yes — it is online and self-paced with a certificate on completion, and CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service, counting towards your CPD and revalidation.
Accused of a boundaries breach with patients or colleagues: what should you do first?
Take advice from your defence organisation, indemnity provider or union before you reply to anyone. Keep every message and record as it is, do not contact the patient or colleague, write a private timeline for your adviser, and note any deadline in your regulator’s letter.
Is a relationship with a colleague a boundaries breach?
Not always. The GMC’s guidance says relationships between colleagues who both agree are a private matter, but boundaries must still be kept and the risk is higher where one person has power over the other’s work. Unwanted sexual comments, messages or behaviour towards a colleague are a breach.
Does it matter that the patient agreed to the relationship?
It does not remove your responsibility. The GPhC’s guidance says the pharmacy professional is responsible for the boundary even when a relationship is agreed by everyone involved, and the GMC, GDC and HCPC standards all look at how you used your position.
Should I apologise to the patient or colleague straight away?
Take advice first. A message to the person while a complaint is open can be seen as pressure. Your adviser can tell you whether and how an apology should be made, and your written reflection can show you understand the effect on them.
When should I start a boundaries course after an allegation?
As soon as you have taken advice. A course and written reflection dated soon after the allegation show that you acted on it yourself, and they are dated evidence of insight and remediation that you can choose to include in your response.
The CPD courses linked from this guide, Professional Boundaries for Clinicians and Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues, are by Probity & Ethics, written by Dr Shehzad Iqbal, CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service (provider no. 13197) and offered since 2020.
