Skip to content
Certified by The CPD Certification Service, UK
Probity & Ethics banner with the words "Facing a Fitness to Practise Investigation?" beside a drawing of a document with a shield and a tick

Facing a Fitness to Practise Investigation?

What happens at each investigation stage and which CPD courses fit your concern.

Dr Shehzad Iqbal

Share

Key Takeaways

  • In a fitness to practise investigation, your regulator gathers evidence, asks for your response and then decides whether the case goes further.
  • At the GMC, NMC and GDC, two case examiners decide the outcome of the investigation.
  • At the HCPC, an Investigating Committee Panel decides in private whether there is a case to answer.
  • You do not have to comment when an investigation opens, but an early, detailed response can help.
  • The HCPC and GDC give 28 days to comment on the allegations.
  • NMC case examiners weigh your insight, the steps you have taken and the risk of the concern happening again.
  • Facing a fitness to practise investigation? Our Probity & Ethics fitness to practise course, the CPD course Fitness to Practise for Healthcare Professionals, supports your response.

What does the investigation stage of fitness to practise mean?

A concern reaches your regulator first. The regulator then decides whether it can deal with it and whether it is serious enough to look into. How that first letter arrives, and the deadlines in the first weeks, are covered in our guide to a fitness to practise complaint. What the phrase itself means, and how impairment is judged, is in our guide what is fitness to practise?

This guide picks up at the next point: the regulator has opened an investigation. From here, its staff collect the facts, send them to you, ask for your account, and then pass the whole file to the people who decide whether the case closes or moves on to a hearing. It is the part of a case where your own response and remediation can still change the outcome before any panel sits.

What does the regulator gather during an investigation?

Each regulator describes its own steps, but the evidence it collects follows the concern.

  • GMC. Its guide for doctors, “Our fitness to practise processes”, says the GMC tells you about the concern, asks for details of your employers and checks with your employer whether there are other concerns. Depending on the case, it may obtain documents and medical records, witness statements, expert reports on clinical matters, and performance, health or English language assessments. It then shares the evidence with you and asks for your comments.
  • NMC. The NMC’s guidance “Gathering information” says investigators seek documentary evidence of the facts, speak to the people involved and look at the wider context you were working in, not only your own actions. You are asked to respond at the start and again at the end of the investigation, and witness statements are sent to you.
  • HCPC. The page “What our investigation would involve” says the HCPC gathers information from different sources and may contact your employer. It then checks what it has against its threshold criteria before it drafts formal allegations.
  • GPhC. Its “Guidance for pharmacy professionals facing a concern” says the GPhC may give you a copy of the concern and ask for a response, visit the pharmacy to gather evidence and take witness statements, and, for a health concern, ask for health information or a medical examination.

Keep a copy of everything you receive and everything you send, with dates. Read each witness statement and expert report closely: these are the papers the decision makers will read.

How does each regulator investigate, and who decides at the end?

The table sets out who makes the decision at the end of the investigation, and the response deadline where the regulator’s own page gives one.

RegulatorWho decides at the endYour response
GMC (doctors)Two case examiners, one medical and one non-medical. The Investigation Committee decides if you dispute a proposed warning.You do not have to comment when the investigation opens, and you can comment at any point. You see the evidence and can comment before the decision.
NMC (nurses, midwives, nursing associates)Two case examiners, one a registered nurse or midwife and one lay person. If they disagree, the Investigating Committee decides.Asked to respond at the start and at the end. You do not have to, but an early, detailed response can open up options such as undertakings or advice.
HCPC (health and care professionals)An Investigating Committee Panel of three, meeting in private on the papers.28 days from the letter with the draft allegation, with up to 28 days more on request.
GDC (dental professionals)Two case examiners, one clinical and one lay.28 days to comment on the allegations; ask your caseworker if you need more time.
GPhC (pharmacy professionals)After the investigation the GPhC decides whether to refer the case to its Investigating Committee or its Fitness to Practise Committee.You may be asked for a response to the concern. The GPhC aims to finish within a year.

The outcomes at the end are close across the regulators. The GMC can close the case, close it with advice, issue a warning, agree undertakings or refer you to a Medical Practitioners Tribunal. NMC case examiners can close the case, give advice or a warning, propose undertakings or refer you to the Fitness to Practise Committee. GDC case examiners can add a letter of advice, a published warning or a referral to a practice committee. The HCPC panel decides only whether there is a case to answer, and the GPhC Investigating Committee can close a case with advice or a warning, put agreements in place or refer it for a full hearing. What happens at a hearing is in our guide on how to prepare for a fitness to practise hearing.

What should you do first once an investigation opens?

  1. Take advice. Contact your defence organisation, indemnity provider or union before you send anything. The GDC and HCPC pages both point you to this.
  2. Cooperate. The GMC and NMC both say their standards ask you to cooperate with an investigation, for example by giving details of where you work. Not commenting on the allegations yet is different from not cooperating.
  3. Read the allegation word by word. Note what is said, about whom, and which standard it points to. Separate the facts you accept from the facts you dispute.
  4. Write your timeline. The HCPC suggests a response can hold a timeline of events, any learning from them and the steps you have taken. That shape works for every regulator.
  5. Start remediation now. Remediation started early has a history by the time the decision makers read your file. A late certificate dated the week before a decision shows less.

If there is a serious risk, the NMC, GDC and GPhC say a committee can be asked for an interim order to restrict or suspend your registration while the investigation goes on. The GDC says that otherwise you can keep working in your current role.

What do the decision makers look for at the end of an investigation?

The NMC’s guidance “How case examiners decide there is a case to answer” sets out the questions in plain words. Case examiners ask how much insight you have shown, what steps you have taken to address the failings, what the risk is of the failings happening again, and how good your reflection is. They also ask whether the concern is one that can be easily addressed.

GDC case examiners ask whether there is a “real prospect” of the allegations being proved and whether your fitness to practise is impaired now. The HCPC panel asks whether there is “a realistic prospect of proving the allegation at a final hearing”. Neither test is about punishment: each asks what the risk is today. So the investigation stage is where insight and remediation matter, because they speak to the risk now.

A written reflection works best when it names the concern, says what you understand went wrong and its effect on the patient or colleague, and says what you now do differently, with dates. Our Module on Insight (£49, 1.5 CPD hours) works through that first part on its own if insight is the gap.

Which course fits each kind of concern?

Match the remediation to what the allegation is about. Each course below is £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, with a certificate on completion.

  • A boundaries concern with a patient or a colleague, including dual relationships, messages or social media contact: our professional boundaries course, Professional Boundaries for Clinicians.
  • An allegation of unprofessional conduct, such as behaviour at work, communication or teamwork: our professionalism course, Professionalism for Healthcare Professionals.
  • An allegation of unethical conduct, such as consent, confidentiality or a conflict between duties: our medical ethics course.
  • An allegation of dishonesty or a probity concern, such as records, claims about yourself, money or declarations: our probity course, Probity for Healthcare Professionals.

Beside the course for your concern, Fitness to Practise for Healthcare Professionals covers the process itself: how fitness to practise works with each regulator, the question the regulator is asking, what decision makers look for at each stage, and insight, reflection and remediation, ending with a reflection on your own practice.

Doctors and nurses can see every course that fits a concern on our GMC remediation courses and NMC remediation courses pages.

How do the certificate and reflection fit your response?

Send them with your written response to the allegations, so they are in the file the case examiners or the committee read. Put the certificate beside a reflection in your own words that links what you learned to the concern: one without the other shows less. Add any other evidence of change, such as an audit of your notes, feedback from colleagues or a supervisor’s report. Each course and module also counts towards your CPD record, so the same work serves your next appraisal, revalidation or renewal.

Book now: our fitness to practise course

For healthcare professionals on every register facing an investigation

Fitness to Practise for Healthcare Professionals

How fitness to practise works with each regulator, what decision makers look for at each stage, and insight, reflection and remediation for your response. Probity & Ethics is CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service (provider no. 13197).

  • £79 (£50 with Bulk Buy 10)
  • 2 CPD hours
  • Certificate on completion

Please note

This guide is general information, not legal advice. No course decides the outcome of a case. Speak to your defence organisation, indemnity provider or union before you send anything to your regulator.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which course should I take for a complaint or investigation?

Our CPD certified and accredited course for this follows your regulator’s standards; pair it with a written reflection that names the standard engaged.

Will a course help my fitness to practise case?

A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which case examiners or an investigating committee look for — strongest with a written reflection and changes in your practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.

When should I send the certificate and reflection?

With your written response, before case examiners or an investigating committee decide — or before a fitness to practise hearing or a review if the case has gone further.

Can I finish the course before my deadline, and is it CPD accredited?

Yes — it is online and self-paced with a certificate on completion, and CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service, counting towards your CPD and revalidation.

Facing a Fitness to Practise Investigation?

Your regulator has decided a concern needs looking into. It gathers evidence, shares it with you and asks for your comments, and at the end case examiners or an investigating committee decide whether to close the case, give advice or a warning, agree undertakings or refer it to a hearing. Take advice, respond to the facts and start remediation that matches the concern.

Do I have to respond during a fitness to practise investigation?

No regulator forces you to comment, but the GMC and NMC both say an early, detailed response can help, and the HCPC says a response helps its panel decide. The HCPC and GDC give 28 days to comment on the allegations, and the HCPC can allow up to 28 days more.

What evidence does a regulator gather in an investigation?

The GMC lists documents from your employer or the person who raised the concern, including medical records, witness statements, expert reports on clinical matters, and performance, health or English language assessments. The NMC also looks at the wider context you were working in, and the GPhC may visit the pharmacy.

Can I keep working during a fitness to practise investigation?

The GDC says you can keep working in your current role during its investigation. The GDC, NMC and GPhC can seek an interim order from a committee to restrict or suspend registration while the investigation goes on, if there is a serious risk.

How long does a fitness to practise investigation take?

The GPhC says it aims to complete its investigations in less than a year and to update you every two months. The other regulators covered here do not give a set length on the pages read for this guide.

The CPD courses linked from this guide, Fitness to Practise for Healthcare Professionals, Module on Insight, Professional Boundaries for Clinicians and Professionalism for Healthcare Professionals, are by Probity & Ethics, written by Dr Shehzad Iqbal, CPD certified and accredited by The CPD Certification Service (provider no. 13197) and offered since 2020.

Basket 0 Total £0.00